2007 - Woodland Wanderers

2006 - BSC Raiders

2005 - BSC Raiders

2004 - BSC Raiders

2003 - BSC Raiders

2002 - Celtic

2001 - Aurora Arsenal

2000 - Celtic

1999 - Aurora Arsenal

1998 - Roos FC

1997 - LSC Strikers

1996 - LSC Strikers

1995 - Black Stars

1994 - Clarence SC

1993 - Buffalo Dynamo

1992 - Depew Kickers

1991 - D-5 Elders

1990 - Amherst Arsenal SC

1989 - Clarence Senior SC

1988 - Buffalo SC

1987 - Buffalo SC

1986 - Grand Prix Garage SC

1985 - Vasilis Restaurant SC

1984 - Clarence Senior SC 

1983 - Buffalo SC III

1982 - West Seneca SC

1981 - West Seneca SC

1980 - Buffalo SC II

1979 - Buffalo Italia 

1968 - Sauer Soccer Club

1962 - Buffalo Italians

1959 - Niagara Falls Italian Kickers

1958 - D'Annuncio Soccer Club

1956 - Polanie Soccer Club

1955 - Polanie Soccer Club

1930 - Lackawanna Hispanos

1928 - Lackawanna Hispanos

1927 - Mackenzies of Niagara Falls

1926 - Buffalo Hungarians

1925 - Buffalo Rangers